| Exempt Members of Company 5 | |
| *Deceased | |
| Robert Abner | Donald Lynch |
| *Andrew Bain (Chief 83,85,86) | *George Luckman |
| Jorge Barreto | John Mathisen |
| *John Behnken | *John McClellan |
| *Al Bently | Clyde McMurdy |
| Thomas Bergen | *George McNamara |
| John Bogert | *Emile Meyer |
| *Robert Campbell | *Emil Meyers |
| *William Cardiff | Robert Minarick (Chief 1989-90) |
| Richard Cochrane | Robert Morgenfruh |
| Robert Coe | *Clayton Morley |
| *Albert Colemen (Chief 42-50) | Russell Nastasi |
| Richard Conner | Sean O'Brien |
| *Jay Cox (Chief 66) | *Paul Peters |
| Harold Coyle (Chief 59-60) | Robert Plavier (Chief 1979,80,87,88) |
| *Robert Cromley | *Harry Redding |
| David Cunningham | *Robert Reid |
| *Edward Dannic (Chief 51-55) | Doug Roberts |
| Jack DeNoble | *John Robinson |
| *Albert Dercksen | *Robert Roy |
| Robert Franco | *Rich Saunders (Chief 1998) |
| *Robert Fulton | *T.J. Sausville |
| *Kenneth Furber | *George Schaffer |
| *Edward Galinis | *Stephen Sebeck |
| Raymond Gavlak | *James Thompson (Chief 1970,71,73,74) |
| *Bradford Gesbocker | James TIger |
| Wayne Giampietro | F.C. Trainor |
| *Richard Gott | Gary Trump |
| Robert Grundy | Ronald Trump |
| *Thomas Harrington | Elbert Tuttle |
| *Arne Henriksen | *Richard Villee |
| *Everett Hess | Allan Voorhis |
| Mark Hill (Chief 2003-2005) | Art Walker |
| *Dean Jacquin (Chief 1964,65,69) | Robert Wanek |
| William Jansen | *Joseph Warner (Chief 1961,62,63) |
| *David Jasinski (Chief 1975) | Barry Weiner (Chief 2001-2002) |
| *Walter Jasinski (Chief 1956-58) | *Henry Westphal |
| Peter Kaminski (Chief 1967-68) | *Austin Whitney |
| *Charles Kess | *Hugh Wisely |
| *John Kuzman | *Leonard Zarpentine |
| *Louis Larsen | |
